Recapitalizations: What Happens When a Startup Resets Its Cap Table
MicroVentures Logo MicroVentures Logo MicroVentures Logo MicroVentures Logo
Blog

Diversification

Recapitalizations: What Happens When a Startup Resets Its Cap Table

Bill Clark

Share
Recapitalizations: What Happens When a Startup Resets Its Cap Table

Recapitalization, Startups, and Private Equity

A startup’s cap table can become increasingly complicated as it raises multiple rounds of financing. Different classes of preferred stock, liquidation preferences, convertible securities, and employee equity can all affect how ownership and proceeds are distributed. In some cases, a company may decide that its existing capital structure no longer works for the business or for attracting new investment.

A recapitalization can help reset that structure, but it can also significantly change the economics for existing shareholders. In this week’s blog, our team at MicroVentures takes a look at why startups pursue recapitalizations, how they can affect investors, and what to consider if a portfolio company decides to pursue a recapitalization.

What Is a Recapitalization?

A recapitalization, or “recap,” is a restructuring of a company’s existing capital structure, which consists of varying share classes and the rights and preferences given to those classes. Unlike a traditional funding round, where a startup primarily issues new securities to raise capital, a recap can change the rights, ownership percentages, and liquidation preferences, attached to securities that are already outstanding.

These changes can take several forms. A company might convert existing preferred shares into a new class of stock, reduce or modify liquidation preferences, change conversion terms, issue new shares, or combine several of these actions. As a result, investors may emerge from the recap with different ownership percentages, rights, or preferences than they had before.

For example, assume a startup raised $300 million by issuing several classes of preferred shares with liquidation preferences layered on top of each other. The most recent preferred round valued the company at $1 billion. It begins seeking new capital, however incoming investors only value the business at $200M. At that price, the existing preferred share classes dominate the preference stack above of common shareholders, leaving little incentive for employees and the executive team to continue operating. The company can recapitalize, converting existing preferred shares into common shares, reducing the liquidation preferences attached to earlier rounds, and issuing new shares to incoming investors. This leaves shareholders with different ownership percentages and priorities than they held before.

Why Would a Startup Recapitalize?

A startup may pursue a recap when its existing capital structure no longer reflects its financial or operating position. This can happen after a company raises several preferred rounds at increasingly high valuations, only for growth to slow or market conditions to change.

In that situation, existing liquidation preferences and other investor rights can make it difficult to attract new capital, particularly if a large portion of a future exit would go to earlier preferred shareholders. A recap can restructure those securities and create a capital structure that better reflects the company’s current value. It may also simplify the cap table or create additional equity to retain and incentivize employees.

The reason for the recap matters. A company proactively restructuring its cap table to attract new investment is often negotiating from a position of relative strength; it can weigh multiple offers and structure terms that preserve incentives for its employees.

A company recapitalizing because it’s nearly out of cash has far less leverage, and the terms of a recap often reflect that in the form of steeper preferences, tighter control provisions, or pay-to-play provisions that penalize earlier investors who don’t participate in the new round.

A recapitalization may also occur as part of restructuring for a private equity investment or acquisition.

What Happens to Existing Investors?

For existing investors, a recapitalization can significantly change their ownership and rights. Existing shares may be converted into a new class of stock, while newly issued equity can further dilute their stake. A new investor providing needed capital, for example, may receive a significant portion of the recapitalized company, leaving existing shareholders with a smaller percentage than they held before the transaction.

This is especially true for a recapitalization as a result of private equity involvement, where recaps often result in the PE firm gaining majority ownership of the company.

Some recaps may also include pay-to-play provisions that require existing investors to participate in the new financing to maintain certain rights or preferences. Investors that do not participate could lose preferred terms or have their shares converted into a different class.

Governance may also change, as new investors could receive board seats, voting or consent rights, or other protections. Depending on the company’s governing documents and existing securities, some of these changes may require approval from certain shareholders or classes of preferred stock.

A recap can also affect how the company is viewed in future financings. Similar to a down round, a transaction that resets the company’s valuation, ownership, or investor rights may raise questions for future investors about the company’s performance, financing needs, and management competence. Existing investors may therefore have to weigh these potential drawbacks against the benefit of the company securing the capital it needs to continue operating.

Why Do Liquidation Preferences Matter?

A recap can also change how proceeds would be distributed in a future exit. As a company completes multiple preferred rounds, liquidation preferences can accumulate and create a preference overhang.

Suppose a startup has raised $75 million of preferred capital but is now worth approximately $50 million. If those investors collectively have $75 million in liquidation preferences, common shareholders may receive little or nothing in an exit near the company’s current value.

Reducing or restructuring those preferences could give common shareholders more opportunity to participate in future proceeds. However, existing preferred shareholders may have to give up some of their previous protections in the process.

How Can a Recap Affect Employees?

Employee equity can become an issue when a company’s valuation falls. Employees may hold options with exercise prices based on a higher valuation, or common equity may sit well below preferred capital that its potential value has become limited.

A recap can help reset those incentives through a new option pool, replacement equity awards, or other changes that give employees an opportunity to participate in future appreciation. Restoring the potential value of employee equity may also help the company retain key employees. Any additional equity issued to employees, however, can further dilute existing shareholders.

What Are the Terms of the New Financing?

If a recap includes a new financing, both the source and terms of that capital can provide important context. Existing investors may lead the transaction because they continue to believe in the company, while a new investor may be willing to provide capital only if the existing cap table is restructured first.

New financing may include senior liquidation preferences, warrants, or other rights that place new investors ahead of existing shareholders. Investors should therefore look beyond the new valuation and consider how changes to preferences, ownership, and other terms affect the economics of the investment.

Is the Recap Solving the Underlying Problem?

Restructuring a cap table can address financing and incentive issues, but it does not necessarily fix the problems that led to the recap.

If a startup struggled because of slowing growth, high spending, product delays, or weak customer demand, changing its capital structure alone will not solve those challenges. Investors should consider what the company plans to do differently and whether the new capital provides enough runway to execute that plan.

The amount of runway provided by any new financing is also important. A company that raises enough capital to reach meaningful operating or financial milestones may be in a much stronger position than one that receives only enough funding for another few months.

Final Thoughts

A recapitalization can give a startup an opportunity to reset a capital structure that no longer reflects the realities of the business. It may make new financing possible, reduce preference overhang, or restore employee incentives, but it can also significantly dilute existing shareholders or change the rights attached to their investment.

For private investors, understanding why a company needs a recap can be just as important as understanding the transaction itself. Changes to ownership, liquidation preferences, investor rights, and the terms of new capital can reshape the economics of an investment, while the company’s ability to address the underlying challenges that led to the recap may ultimately determine whether the restructuring is successful.

Are you ready to invest in startups? Sign up for a MicroVentures account to start investing!

Want to learn more about investing in startups? Check out the following MicroVentures blogs to learn more:

Important disclosure

The information presented here is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be, nor should it be construed or used as, comprehensive offering documentation for any security, investment, tax or legal advice, a recommendation, or an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, an interest, directly or indirectly, in any company. Investing in both early-stage and later-stage companies carries a high degree of risk. A loss of an investor’s entire investment is possible, and no profit may be realized. Investors should be aware that these types of investments are illiquid and should anticipate holding until an exit occurs.